Christmas Music Trivia: Test Your Carol Knowledge

Christmas Music Trivia: Test Your Carol Knowledge
Christmas Music Trivia: Test Your Carol Knowledge

Last updated: October 4, 2026

Christmas Music Trivia: Test Your Carol Knowledge
Photo credit: David Beale (via Unsplash)

How to Use This List

These questions focus specifically on the music side of Christmas trivia, separate from the
broader history and movie trivia covered elsewhere on this site, useful for a themed music-only
round.

Carol Origins (Sample Questions)

Q: What year was “Silent Night” first performed? A: 1818.
Q: What instrument was “Silent Night” first performed with, in the popular story about a broken church organ? A: Guitar. The organ detail is a well-known tale and may be legend.
Q: “O Holy Night” was originally written in what language? A: French.

3 Trivia Categories 1 Carol origins Who wrote it, when, and why 2 Modern Christmas music Artist recognition for pop-era standards 3 Music facts & records Surprising trivia and historical records
The three categories this music trivia guide covers.

Modern Christmas Music (Sample Questions)

Q: Which artist recorded “All I Want for Christmas Is You”? A: Mariah
Carey.
Q: What band recorded “Last Christmas”? A: Wham!.
Q: “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” was originally recorded by which artist?
A: Brenda Lee.

Music Facts and Records (Sample Questions)

Q: What’s notable about “Jingle Bells” and Thanksgiving? A: A popular story says it was written for Thanksgiving, but this is not proven. The song is about a winter sleigh ride.
Q: Which classic carol is one of the most recorded songs in history? A: Silent
Night.

More Carol and Hymn Questions

Q: “Joy to the World” was based on which book of the Bible? A: Psalm 98, from the Book of Psalms.
Q: What is the Latin title of “O Come, All Ye Faithful”? A: “Adeste Fideles.”
Q: Good King Wenceslas looked out on the feast of which saint? A: St. Stephen (December 26).
Q: Which American clergyman wrote the words to “O Little Town of Bethlehem”? A: Phillips Brooks.
Q: Who wrote “We Three Kings” in 1857? A: John Henry Hopkins Jr.
Q: Which poet wrote the words of “In the Bleak Midwinter”? A: Christina Rossetti.
Q: Which composer set “In the Bleak Midwinter” to music? A: Gustav Holst.
Q: Which carol, dating from the sixteenth century, includes the refrain “Lully, lullay”? A: The Coventry Carol.
Q: Which carol is traditionally the opening hymn at the King’s College Festival of Nine Lessons and Carols, with a solo first verse by a boy chorister? A: “Once in Royal David’s City.”
Q: What does “Noel” in “The First Noel” mean? A: Christmas (from the French).
Q: Which carol is also called “Luther’s Cradle Hymn,” although Martin Luther did not write it? A: “Away in a Manger.”
Q: Which carol was written as a plea for peace during the Cuban missile crisis in 1962? A: “Do You Hear What I Hear?”

Pop, Rock and Soul Christmas Questions

Q: Which singer recorded “Santa Baby” in 1953? A: Eartha Kitt.
Q: Who sang “It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year” in 1963? A: Andy Williams.
Q: Which singer recorded “Blue Christmas” in 1957? A: Elvis Presley.
Q: Who sang “Feliz Navidad”? A: José Feliciano.
Q: Which band recorded “Fairytale of New York” with Kirsty MacColl? A: The Pogues.
Q: Who wrote and recorded “Wonderful Christmastime” in 1979? A: Paul McCartney.
Q: Which song by John Lennon and Yoko Ono has the subtitle “War Is Over”? A: “Happy Xmas (War Is Over).”
Q: Who recorded “Jingle Bell Rock” in 1957? A: Bobby Helms.
Q: Which singer recorded “Driving Home for Christmas”? A: Chris Rea.
Q: Who sang “A Holly Jolly Christmas” in the 1964 Rudolph special? A: Burl Ives.
Q: Which band recorded “Little Saint Nick”? A: The Beach Boys.
Q: Which singer is known for “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)”? A: Darlene Love.
Q: Who released “Mistletoe” in 2011? A: Justin Bieber.
Q: Who recorded “Merry Christmas Everyone” in 1985? A: Shakin’ Stevens.

Songs With Surprising Stories

Q: “Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow!” was written during what kind of weather? A: A summer heat wave in Hollywood in 1945.
Q: Which song, originally an instrumental by Leroy Anderson, later gained lyrics by Mitchell Parish? A: “Sleigh Ride.”
Q: In which 1951 film did the song “Silver Bells” first appear? A: The Lemon Drop Kid.
Q: Which Christmas song was written by Katherine Kennicott Davis in 1941 and originally called “Carol of the Drum”? A: “The Little Drummer Boy.”
Q: Which Austrian town is closely associated with the first performance of “Silent Night”? A: Oberndorf.
Q: Which Handel work includes the Hallelujah Chorus, which audiences traditionally stand for? A: Messiah.
Q: In which city was Handel’s Messiah first performed in 1742? A: Dublin.
Q: In which film did Bing Crosby first sing “White Christmas”? A: Holiday Inn (1942).
Q: Who composed “Carol of the Bells” based on a Ukrainian folk chant? A: Mykola Leontovych.

A Note on “Jingle Bells” and Thanksgiving

A popular claim, repeated in the sample questions above, is that “Jingle Bells” was originally written for Thanksgiving. This story is widely repeated, but it is not firmly established. The song was written by James Lord Pierpont and first published in the 1850s under the title “One Horse Open Sleigh,” and its lyrics are about a winter sleigh ride rather than any specific holiday. Historians disagree about where and why it was first performed, so it is safest to say that the Thanksgiving origin is a popular story rather than a documented fact.

How to Run a Music Quiz Night

A music quiz is easy to host. Choose three or four categories, such as carols, pop songs, film music and trivia. For a recognition round, play ten-second clips of songs and ask players to name the title and artist. Give a point for each correct answer, with a bonus for naming the year. Use a phone or a speaker, and prepare the clips in advance to avoid fumbling.

  • Teams: divide guests into teams of three or four for more conversation.
  • Rounds: keep each one to ten questions and add a tie-breaker.
  • Prizes: chocolates, candy canes or a trophy made from a wrapped box.
  • Variety: include a round of lyrics where players finish the line.

Music Trivia for Children and Families

For younger players, keep the questions simple and visual. Ask them to name a song from the first few notes, to finish a well-known lyric or to guess which instrument makes the sound of sleigh bells. Let them hum tunes for adults to guess, and encourage them to make up their own questions. Make sure the activity is fun and not a test, and that everyone, regardless of age or knowledge, has a chance to contribute.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s a good format for a music-only trivia round?

Mixing origin questions (who wrote it, when) with pure recognition questions (name the artist) keeps a music round varied rather than testing only one type of knowledge.

Was Jingle Bells originally a Christmas song?

Its words describe a winter sleigh ride and do not mention Christmas. A popular story says it was first written for Thanksgiving, but that is not proven.

What’s the most-recorded Christmas song in history?

Silent Night is frequently cited as one of the most recorded songs of all time, across an enormous range of artists and languages.