
Short answer: “Would you rather” is a simple choice game, each round presents two options and players pick (and usually defend) one. Christmas versions work for almost any group size or age, need no supplies, and are a good filler between other activities or a quiet way to pass time on a long car ride.
Last updated: November 2, 2026.
How to Play
One person reads a question aloud, offering two Christmas-themed options, and each player says which they’d choose, often along with a quick reason why. There’s no scoring required, the fun is in the choice and the discussion it sparks, though you can add a simple point system (majority answer wins a point, or everyone votes on the funniest reasoning) if your group likes a bit of competition. It works well as a standalone activity around the dinner table, in the car, or as a quick icebreaker before a bigger party gets going.
Classic Christmas Questions
Always get a real tree or Always get an artificial tree?
Open one gift on Christmas Eve or Wait until Christmas morning for all of them?
Have a white Christmas every year or Have a warm, sunny Christmas every year?
Watch the same Christmas movie every year or Never watch a Christmas movie again?
Only eat Christmas dinner leftovers for a week or Never have Christmas leftovers again?
Decorate the tree alone or Decorate the whole house with your whole family?
Get a gift you don’t like from someone you love or Get a gift you love from a stranger?
Sing carols door to door or Host a big Christmas party?
Have Christmas dinner at noon or Have Christmas dinner at 9pm?
Spend Christmas Day traveling or Spend Christmas Day entirely at home?
Silly and Ridiculous Questions
Find out Santa is real or Find out Santa was always your parents?
Get coal in your stocking every year or Never get a stocking again?
Have Rudolph’s red nose for a day or Have Frosty’s ability to build a snowman instantly?
Be stuck in an elevator with a bad Christmas song on loop or Be stuck in traffic on Christmas Eve?
Accidentally regift something to the person who gave it to you or Forget someone’s name at a party and have to guess?
Wear an ugly Christmas sweater every day this month or Never wear anything festive again?
Have glitter stuck in your house until next Christmas or Step on a Lego hidden under wrapping paper?
Eat a whole fruitcake by yourself or Eat a whole raw gingerbread house?
Have your Christmas lights visible from space or Have the quietest, most understated lights on the street?
Lose power on Christmas morning or Lose power on New Year’s Eve?
Food and Treats Questions
Only eat cookies for Christmas dessert forever or Only eat pie for Christmas dessert forever?
Have a Christmas dinner with no dessert or Have a Christmas dinner that’s only desserts?
Drink hot chocolate every day in December or Drink eggnog every day in December?
Eat Christmas dinner cold or Eat it two hours late, but hot?
Give up turkey forever or Give up stuffing forever?
Have to make the whole Christmas dinner yourself every year or Never be allowed to cook anything and always bring store-bought?
Only snack on candy canes all season or Only snack on gingerbread men all season?
Have unlimited cookies but no milk or Have unlimited milk but no cookies?
Family and Tradition Questions
Spend Christmas with your whole extended family or Spend Christmas with just your immediate family?
Host Christmas dinner every year or Travel to someone else’s house every year?
Have to answer every awkward family question honestly or Dodge every question with a joke all day?
Share a room with a sibling for the holidays or Have your own space but miss the late-night chats?
Have a family game night every Christmas or Have a family movie night every Christmas?
Be in charge of the whole Christmas budget or Have no say in the budget at all?
Get the same gift as a sibling every year or Never know what anyone else got?
Tips for a Better Round
- Ask for a reason, not just an answer. “Why?” usually produces the funniest or most revealing part of the round.
- Mix easy and hard questions. A few genuinely difficult choices keep the game interesting rather than every answer being obvious.
- Adjust for the room. Save the sillier or more personal questions for a group that already knows each other well, and lead with the classic or food questions for a mixed or newer group.
- Let kids make up their own. Younger players often enjoy inventing a question as much as answering one, and it keeps a long game fresh.
Pairing This With Other Activities
“Would you rather” works well as a warm-up before a longer game night, our Christmas party games guide covers more structured options once the group is ready for something bigger. It’s also a natural fit for the quieter moments of a scavenger hunt break or a long car trip during holiday travel.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you play Christmas Would You Rather?
One person reads two Christmas-themed options aloud, and each player picks which they’d choose, often explaining why. No supplies or scoring are required.
How many Would You Rather questions are in this list?
35 questions across four categories: classic, silly, food, and family and tradition questions.
What age group is this game good for?
Most ages. Stick to the classic and food questions for younger kids or mixed groups, and save the sillier or more personal questions for a group that knows each other well.
Can this game be played in the car?
Yes, it needs no supplies or setup, which makes it a good way to pass time during holiday travel.
